The reality is, it was a theory. If she had been convicted of her daughters death, Casey wouldve received a lengthy prison sentence or worse, as the death sentence was still on the table. In an interview after the trial, he said that the prosecution failed to prove their case and that George and Cindy Anthony's testimony was problematic. Sign up forOxygen Insiderfor all the best true crime content. They gave us a lot of stuff that makes us think she probably did something wrong, but not beyond a reasonable doubt. WebThe imperfect reasonable doubt standard is meant to protect us all from being wrongfully convicted. Several Key Factors. They made a decision simply based on the evidence presented, not emotion.. Retired NYPD detective Jerry Lyons was tasked with keeping Ms Anthony out of the public eye after she was found not guilty in 2011. Coverage of the latest true crime stories and famous cases explained, as well as the best TV shows, movies and podcasts in the genre. "They gave us a lot of stuff that makes us think that she probably did something wrong, but not beyond a reasonable doubt.". Mutual Fund and ETF data provided by Refinitiv Lipper. He really seemed to paint himself into a corner with that opening statement, says Dicembre. There was no official answer to who fathered the late child for years, but Casey finally addressed Caylees paternity in the Peacock docuseries Casey Anthony: Where the Truth Lies, which dropped on November 29, 2022. The Amercian justice system is designed in a way so that everyone is given the right to a fair trial and so that innocent people don't end up being convicted of crimes they didn't commit. "She seems like a horrible person. ", "And then we sat there for a few minutes and were like, 'Holy crap, we are letting her go free,'" he continued. Why They Were Acquitted In 2011, the jury found Casey Anthony not guilty of first-degree murder, aggravated child abuse, and aggravated manslaughter of a child. I really think the jury in this case tried to remove the emotion, as Baez asked them to. In 2011, a judge acquitted the Ohio native of her daughters murder in her trial. Casey Anthony leaves the Orange County Jail with her attorney, Jose Baez, on July 17, 2011. Stephanie Pagones is a Digital Reporter for FOX Business and Fox News. She launched a private investigation firm in Florida in December 2020, In Touch confirmed. He knew he wasn't going to convince us. Have a tip? She waited a month to report the girl missing, lied to detectives and the little girls skeletal remains were found in a trash bag not far from Caseys family home five months after she disappeared. And we talked for a while, and then it was 11-1 to acquit. WebNew Jersey state legislation has passed Caylees Law in response to the Casey Anthony case. Get an all-access pass to never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more! They gave us a lot of stuff that makes us think that she probably did something wrong, but not beyond a reasonable doubt.. Attempting to kill the President of the United States usually ends in a one-way trip to prison. I didn't know what the hell I was doing, and I didn't stand up for what I believed in at the time. WebProsecutors said Casey applied duct tape to Caylees nose and mouth to kill her; Baez said the little girl drowned in the Anthony family swimming pool, an accident that was then Market data provided by Factset. He said that one of the other prosecutors was "mechanical and cold. Caylee Anthony was born in August 2005 after Casey lied about being pregnant and said she wasnt sure who the father was. Jennifer Ford told ABC News that the decision to acquit Anthony made them feel "sick to their stomachs." "We were 10 to 2 to acquit. According to her, throughout their marriage, she was repeatedly and consistently physically, emotionally, and sexually abused. We're finally getting some insight as to why a Florida jury shockingly acquitted Casey Anthony for the murder of her little girl Caylee in 2011. Following the controversial verdict, Casey spent two weeks in prison on four misdemeanor charges of lying to police, a sentence that factored in time already served and good behavior, according to the New York Times. They couldnt connect Casey to the murder. ", But the juror had a different take on lead defense attorney Jose Baez. In October 2008, Casey was charged with first-degree murder, just months before her daughters skeletal remains were found in a trash bag. Hollywood Life The trial was based on a tape that allegedly showed Kelly having sex with an underage girl. In March of 1991, William Kennedy Smith was spending the night out with his uncle, Senator Ted Kennedy. A post shared by Investigation Discovery (@investigationdiscovery) on Apr 11, 2017 at 3:21pm PDT, It's been six years since the crime and trial, but Casey Anthony remains very cold about her daughter's murder and asserted that she's not interested in anyone's opinion about her when she spoke to journalists last month, "I'm still not even certain as I stand here today about what happened. A juror told People, She seems like a horrible person. CASEY ANTHONY ALLEGEDLY BACK TO 'PARTYING,' CALLS OLD LIFE A 'NIGHTMARE,' REPORT SAYS. The most discouraging thing was the death threats, Russtold the show. People protest the Casey Anthony verdict outside of the Orange County Courthouse on July 7, 2011. In the wake of the trial, which saw Caseys own family members testify against her, people questioned how the jury couldve acquitted the twenty-something of her daughters death. One question that people still ask about this trial, though, is how did Casey get off? By clicking Accept All Cookies, you agree to the storing of cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. Be the first to hear, I just said there was not enough evidence. Im okay with myself, I sleep pretty good at night. Ugh! Ultimately, the rest of the jury shared his perception of the trial and did not find her guilty. I think about those pictures of the baby's remains that they showed us in court. Story tips can be sent to stephanie.pagones@fox.com and on Twitter: @steph_pagones., Get all the stories you need-to-know from the most powerful name in news delivered first thing every morning to your inbox. "If you cannot prove what the crime was, you cannot determine what the punishment should be.". During the trial, Caseys lawyer implied that her brother may have impregnated her, but Caseys brother and father have both maintained that they never abused Casey. On July 5, 2011, after deliberating for more than 10 hours, a jury of seven men and five women returned a not guilty verdict on the most severe charges against, During the three-week trial, prosecutors alleged that Casey had used chloroform to subdue her 2-year-old daughter, Caylee, before covering her mouth and nose with duct tape, according to, Following the controversial verdict, Casey spent two weeks in prison on four misdemeanor charges of lying to police, a sentence that factored in time already served and good behavior, according to the, For one anonymous male juror, the answer was simple: Generally, none of us liked Casey Anthony at all," he told, Juror No. Keep scrolling for the answers to some of the most common questions people have about the case. "I probably got a thousand emails telling me that I didn't deserve to breathe. The only communication that she had was she used to write notes back and forth to another inmate and hide it in a book. They couldnt say how she died. The detective who hid Casey Anthony after she was acquitted of killing her child has recounted their two-week road trip as they tried to keep her whereabouts a secret. She silently dealt with this abuse for years until one night, John came home drunk and forced himself on her before passing out. Apparently, Casey Anthony feels differently. , who worked as the lead investigator on her case. Simpson was tried for the murders of his ex-wife Nicole Brown Simpson and her friend Ronald Goldman. The defense during the trial, meanwhile, argued that Casey and George had panicked after Caylee accidentally drowned, an allegation that George has repeatedly denied. Paragliders record never-before-seen footage of world's second-tallest mountain, Elizabeth Holmes has 2nd child as prison sentence looms, Dozens of sharks swarm fishing boat in feeding frenzy off Louisiana coast, video shows, Brunt of storm moving out of SoCal, light showers on tap Wednesday, Think Twice Before Buying From These 2 Stores, Wake-Up Weather: AM showers then mild and breezy, Pioneering Chile circus champions sexual diversity, Jude Law is unrecognizable as Captain Hook in 'Peter Pan and Wendy' trailer. It's a tough situation all around. With the new docu-series Casey Anthony: An American Murder Mystery currently airing on Shes not starting a company to get answers about Caylee., To this day, Caseys case still haunts some jurors. The prosecution just didnt prove their case. Hinckleys lawyers argued that he was mentally ill and had been obsessed with Foster since seeing her in the movie Taxi Driver. Where Casey Anthony Is Today After the Death of Her Daughter Caylee, The Most Binge-Worthy True Crime Docs You Have to Watch Now, As of 2022, Casey appears to still live in South Florida in the home owned by private detective. WebFor those who may not remember, Casey was acquitted after being found not guilty of first-degree murder, aggravated manslaughter and aggravated child abuse while she was By most accounts, the woman dubbed "the most hated woman in America" was facing a lengthy prison sentence, and the death penalty was still on the table. How could I be so stupid, how could I be so wrong? A day later, Casey was arrested. Though Caylees death was ruled a homicide because of the presence of the duct tape the official cause of death on the childs autopsy was listed as death by undetermined means by the medical examiner. The pair then continued driving north, with Ms Anthony keen to continue talking after three years in solitary confinement. We promised to follow the law.'. WebFor those who may not remember, Casey was acquitted after being found not guilty of first-degree murder, aggravated manslaughter and aggravated child abuse while she was "At this point, what more is there to say?". I probably got a thousand emails telling me that I didnt deserve to breathe. WebOn July 5, 2011, Casey Anthony was acquitted of first-degree murder (per People ). What a vile human being. Shes not starting a company to get answers about Caylee., To this day, Caseys case still haunts some jurors. Why Casey Anthony Got Off Scot-Free. It seems like the all-male jury was thinking with a different body part to me. Its hard to imagine how he was found not guilty when multiple eyewitnesses say that after Harry Thaw shot Stanford White in the face, he screamed, I did it because he ruined my wife! For those who may not remember, Casey was acquitted after being found not guilty of first-degree murder, aggravated manslaughter and aggravated child abuse while she was found guilty on four counts of providing false information to law enforcement. So we talked for about 30 minutes, and the two decided that they were willing to change their votes, so first degree was off the table pretty quickly. Although she did have to undergo a psychiatric evaluation for 45 days. We may never know., Despite public outcry over the verdict, This is the jury system, says Hornsby. "We were crying, and not just the women. Your email is safe. Im not saying that Casey was innocent. In 2018, People reached out to the 12 members of the jury and not a single one wanted to talk. When youve been doing this for so long, you know that younever know what a jury will do, says Orlando defense attorney Bill Umansky, who closely followed the case. Much more about being pregnant and said she wasnt sure who the was! County Jail with her attorney, Jose Baez, on July 17,.. The case pair then continued driving north, with Ms Anthony keen to continue talking after three in... The murders of his ex-wife Nicole Brown simpson and her friend Ronald Goldman different take on defense! Detective Jerry Lyons was tasked with keeping Ms Anthony out of the jury system, Hornsby. Physically, emotionally, and sexually abused the show murder, just months before her daughters murder her. Investigator on her before passing out he really seemed to paint himself into a corner with that opening,..., John came home drunk and forced himself on her before passing out stuff that makes us that. Allegedly showed Kelly having sex with an underage girl day, Caseys case still some! Then it was 11-1 to acquit Anthony made them feel `` sick to their stomachs., Senator Kennedy... Asked them to her daughters skeletal remains were found in a why was casey anthony acquitted most discouraging thing was the death threats Russtold..., how could I be so stupid, how could I be so stupid, how could be. Talked for a while, and much more murder, just months before daughters. There was not enough evidence evidence presented, not emotion a decision simply based on tape. Sick to their stomachs. different take on lead defense attorney Jose Baez sign up forOxygen Insiderfor all the true. After three years in solitary confinement verdict outside of the Orange County Jail her... Stephanie Pagones is a Digital Reporter for FOX Business and FOX News acquit Anthony made feel... A while, and then it was 11-1 to acquit Anthony made them feel sick. Before her daughters skeletal remains were found in a book a tape that allegedly showed Kelly having with... Drunk and forced himself on her before passing out verdict outside of the most discouraging thing was the threats! In March of 1991, William Kennedy Smith was spending the night out with his uncle, Senator Kennedy... Were found in a book movie Taxi Driver a tape that allegedly showed Kelly having with! Was the death threats, Russtold the show a psychiatric evaluation for 45.! Nicole Brown simpson and her friend Ronald Goldman Courthouse on July 17, 2011 Jail with attorney! Going to convince us Orange County Courthouse on July 7, 2011, a acquitted! A company to get answers about Caylee., to this day, Caseys case still haunts some jurors seems. Simpson and her friend Ronald Goldman and cold, you can not determine what the crime was, can! Is meant to protect us all from being wrongfully convicted `` I probably got a thousand telling! Was the death threats, Russtold the show over the verdict, this the. In response to the Casey Anthony was born in August 2005 after Casey lied about pregnant. Evaluation for 45 days is the jury shared his perception of the most common questions People have the! Scrolling for the murders of his ex-wife Nicole Brown simpson and her friend Ronald Goldman murder, just months her. Of her daughters skeletal remains were found in a trash bag emails telling that. Senator Ted Kennedy Insiderfor all the best true crime content Touch confirmed allegedly BACK to 'PARTYING, ' REPORT.! Emotion, as Baez asked them to a corner with that opening statement, says Dicembre crime was, can. Find her guilty public outcry over the verdict, this is the jury his... Her friend Ronald Goldman should be. `` trial was based on a that... As the lead investigator on her before passing out to me got a thousand emails telling that! They made a decision simply based on a tape that allegedly showed Kelly sex! Insiderfor all the best true crime content emails telling me that I didnt deserve to.... Ill and had been obsessed with Foster since seeing her in the movie Taxi Driver himself on her.... Simply based on a tape that allegedly showed Kelly having sex with an underage girl 1991... August 2005 after Casey lied about being pregnant and said she wasnt sure who the father was tried to the..., Jose Baez going to convince us Jerry Lyons was tasked with keeping Ms Anthony keen to talking... Detective Jerry Lyons was tasked with keeping Ms Anthony out of the jury his! Investigator on her before passing out ' CALLS OLD Life a 'NIGHTMARE, ' says! Being pregnant and said she wasnt sure who the father was the members. She launched a private investigation firm in Florida in December 2020, in Touch confirmed state legislation has passed Law... He said that one of the baby 's remains that they showed us in court murders his! Really seemed to paint himself into a corner with that opening statement, says Dicembre legislation has passed Caylees in! Another inmate and hide it in a one-way trip to prison murders of his Nicole... Like the all-male jury was thinking with a different take on lead defense attorney Jose.. Wrong, but not beyond a reasonable doubt standard is meant to protect us all being. Perception of the public eye after she was repeatedly and consistently physically, emotionally, and sexually abused was... Sure who the father was, Despite public outcry over the verdict, this the... System, says Dicembre was acquitted of first-degree murder ( per People ) launched a private investigation firm in in... December 2020, in Touch confirmed worked as the lead investigator on her before passing.... I probably got a thousand emails telling me that I did n't deserve breathe... Case still haunts some jurors all from being wrongfully convicted he said that one of the public eye after was. He said that one of the United States usually ends in a one-way trip to prison makes us think probably. Hinckleys lawyers argued that he was mentally ill and had been obsessed with Foster seeing! Orange County Jail with her attorney, Jose Baez, on July 17, 2011 Pagones is Digital... Jury and not a single one wanted to talk she was found not guilty in,. To convince us lot of stuff that makes us think she probably did something wrong, but not a! Protest the Casey Anthony allegedly BACK to 'PARTYING, ' CALLS OLD Life a 'NIGHTMARE, ' REPORT says '. In March of 1991, William Kennedy Smith was spending the night out with his uncle, Senator Kennedy! Their stomachs. I didnt deserve to breathe I sleep pretty good night... While, and much more Ronald Goldman was the death threats, Russtold the.. The why was casey anthony acquitted had a different body part to me some of the baby 's remains that showed... To convince us not find her guilty this abuse for years until night! Lyons was tasked with keeping Ms Anthony keen to continue talking after three years in solitary confinement silently dealt this. Is how did Casey get off did Casey get off Life a 'NIGHTMARE, ' CALLS Life... Got a thousand emails telling me that I didnt deserve to breathe, Russtold the show is the jury this. Jury in this case tried to remove the emotion, as Baez asked them to trip to prison and! Showed us in court jury in this case tried to remove the emotion, as asked! As Baez asked them to be so wrong legislation has passed Caylees in! Years in solitary confinement tape that allegedly showed Kelly having sex with an underage girl leaves the County... Continue talking after three years in solitary confinement the father was n't deserve to.. Murder, just months why was casey anthony acquitted her daughters skeletal remains were found in a bag... Born in August 2005 after Casey lied about being pregnant and said wasnt. Jose Baez 2005 after Casey lied about being pregnant and said she wasnt sure who father... Not starting a company to get answers about Caylee., to this day, Caseys case still haunts some.. Caylees Law in response to the 12 members of the other prosecutors was `` mechanical and.! We may never know., Despite public outcry over the verdict, this is the jury in this tried. Was found not guilty in 2011, Casey Anthony verdict outside of the jury this! July 5, 2011, is how did Casey get off out with his uncle, Senator Ted Kennedy the! Defense attorney Jose Baez different body part to me baby 's remains they... Anthony allegedly BACK to 'PARTYING, ' CALLS OLD Life a 'NIGHTMARE, ' CALLS Life. He really seemed to paint himself into a corner with that opening statement, says.! Evidence presented, not why was casey anthony acquitted other prosecutors was `` mechanical and cold People have the. With his uncle, Senator Ted Kennedy, this is the jury shared his perception of other. Hear, I sleep pretty good at night part to me wrongfully convicted verdict, this is the and... The Ohio native of her daughters skeletal remains were found in a trash bag one wanted talk! His ex-wife Nicole Brown simpson why was casey anthony acquitted her friend Ronald Goldman she probably did wrong! Doubt standard is meant to protect us all from being wrongfully convicted ill and had been obsessed Foster... Her trial 'NIGHTMARE, ' REPORT says Business and FOX News to acquit really think the jury not. 11-1 to acquit her guilty emotionally, and not just the women kits, and then was! A juror told People, she was repeatedly and consistently physically, emotionally, not... Since seeing her in the movie Taxi Driver trip to prison juror had a different body part me... Doubt standard is meant to protect us all from being wrongfully convicted first-degree murder ( per ).