The fire is considered to be under-ventilated at higher values of >1.0. Later in a fires development, an upper layer begins to form and starts transferring heat to the wall and ceiling surfaces. He found that the damage from the flame plume would extend approximately the width of the fuel for 100kW fires that did not have a ceiling jet form and 3 times the width of the fuel with 300kW fires that did have flame extension under the ceiling. In addition, they may not know where or how to obtain additional information, or how to judge the value of the information in the context of the overall decision. volume4, Articlenumber:4 (2015) During a fully involved compartment fire or when a compartment fire is ventilation-controlled, more complete combustion is achieved at those locations where the mixture is adequate. As the gases rise and expand, they also begin to interact with ventilation openings. These white areas were similar in appearance to clean burn patterns at first glance, but were shown upon closer examination to be differentiated based on smeared, directional appearance with observable water drip marks. Department of Justice, USA, Milke J, Hill S (1997) Full-scale room fire experiments conducted at the University of Maryland. denser material like oak will generally show _____ lines of demarcation than carpet. Regardless of the terminology used, these fire patterns were used as a means to trace the fire back to the location where it started, the area of origin. 1983; Kennedy and Kennedy 1985; Cooke and Ide 1985). One aspect of looking at radiant heat flux is to determine if the secondary object has been raised to a critical temperature or is receiving a critical heat flux where ignition of that object is possible. Twelve thermocouples were mounted in a grid array above the fuel item to capture temperatures for the duration of the tests. The velocity of this air inflow also influences this mixing. Each test fire was conducted for 10min, with the door opened at 5min. Use of damage in fire investigation: a review of fire patterns analysis, research and future direction, https://doi.org/10.1186/s40038-015-0008-4, http://ncfs.ucf.edu/twgfex/docs/Scene_Survey_Results.pdf, http://www.forenseek.org/spip/?A-Decision-Support-System-for,46, www.Merriam-webster.com/dictionary/pattern, https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0. Hicks et al. Thus, the total percentage of participants choosing the correct area increased 3.9% with the inclusion of measurable data as part of the given. ATF, Ammendale, MD, Pattern (2015) Merriam Webster Dictionary. However, Kirk elaborated on what the investigator should look for in evaluating this fire pattern when he stated because of the upward tendency of every fire, some type of inverted conical shape is characteristic, the apex at the bottom being the point of ignition, with the fire rising and spreading (Kirk 1969). The test fires were conducted in identically constructed, finished and furnished living room and bedroom compartments within a burn building. Dissertation, Worcester Polytechnic Institute, Gorbett G, Chapdelaine W (2014) Scientific Method Use, Application and Gap Analysis for Origin Determination. Fire and Arson Investigator Journal of the International Association of Arson Investigators 19:115118, Crofton, MD, Ericson C (1999) Fault Tree Analysis A History. location and elevation). A seven step reasoning process for evaluating damage for determining the area of origin, along with a new definition for the term fire pattern is proposed. Elsevier, Massachusetts (USA), Howard R (1966) Decision Analysis: Applied Decision Theory. As expected, the results indicated that the patterns generated by the polyurethane foam fire had greater uncertainty than the natural gas and gasoline pool fires. Fire investigators have historically relied upon damage as a means to conclude where a fire originated. Despite this warning, several textbooks and journal articles discuss that an investigator can prescribe a 45min duration of burning for every 1-inch of char depth (Stickney 1984; Kennedy and Kennedy 1985; Swab 1985). 2003). Fire and Arson Investigator Journal of the International Association of Arson Investigators 9:2629, Crofton, MD, Tanaka T, Nakaya I, Yoshida M (1985) Full Scale Experiments for Determining the Burning Conditions to be Applied to Toxicity Tests. walls, ceiling, contents) within a compartment. This method or a similar method should be further explored using the work done for gypsum wallboard (Gorbett et al. The other difficulty for forensic scientists investigating fires is that the observations of damage after the fire may often times be independent of the path taken by the fire making it difficult to identify where the fire started. The first published fire pattern tests was in 1984 (Custer and Wright 1984). If the mud and tape were present to cover the drywall seams, then typically the damage is lesser at this area. endstream endobj startxref Only later did the literature express this conical shape as two-dimensional shapes, including triangular shapes, columnar shapes, V-patterns, U-patterns and hourglass-patterns (Barracato 1979; Cooke and Ide 1985; Kennedy and Kennedy 1985). Google Scholar, Babrauskas V (1981) Will the second item ignite? These results were found to be statistically significant using a chi square distribution yielding a p-value of 0.006. This should and generally is, close to the low point of the burn (Kirk 1969). The Law Enforcement Assistance Administration (LEAA) documented many of the myths about using the visible appearance of damage to identify arson with the visible appearance of char being one of the predominant misconceptions (Boudreau et al. Several researchers have identified significant changes in damage around drywall seams (Claflin 2014; Gorbett et al. 2010). The same proponents of identifying pour patterns as being indicative of an ignitable liquid, also promulgated that holes in floors were indicative of ignitable liquids being used (Battle and Weston 1960; Fitch and Porter 1968; Barracato 1979; Smith 1983; Harmer et al. This first edition was also the first time fire patterns were organized into one document. The wall construction was varied between a single sheet of gypsum wallboard with wood framing, a gypsum wallboard front and back with wood framing and gypsum wallboard front and back with fiberglass batt insulation in the voids of the wood framing. Correct determination of the origin depends on the correct. The focus of his process was similar to the others in describing that the area of origin will be located at the greatest area of damage and the investigators should focus on identifying the low burn damage areas and using conical shapes. fire patterns) in an attempt to reconstruct the fires development. Typically, investigators look at the face of the wallboard and make a visible determination of the DOFD. The early texts on fire investigations promoted the use of identifying the varying degree of charring throughout the compartment to assist with origin determination. Interpretation of the causal factors for the generation of the fire patterns was next appraised. In fact, a recent sentinel event analysis of wrongful convictions found that this one misconception is the most common factor in wrongful arson convictions (Bieber 2014). 1997). Gorbett, G.E., Meacham, B.J., Wood, C.B. 2013). Paper presented at the International Symposium on Fire Investigations. As explained in this method, the two-dimensional shapes and patterns would be formed by the overall three-dimensional plume as it intersected these surfaces resulting in V-shape and U-shape patterns on walls, contents and vertical structural member and Radial-shaped patterns on the ceiling and horizontal obstructions. Cox provided a process for better interpreting the compartment fire dynamics that is still under development and has not undergone a major field test for user application. A survey was conducted to evaluate the proficiency of professional fire investigators at determining the area of origin when provided with photographs and measurable data from a test (Tinsley and Gorbett 2013). Thirty-nine novice raters performed an analysis of damage to a wall surface, completing 66 ratings first without the DOFD method and second, repeated rating with the new DOFD method. Learn. A scale ranging from 0 to 6 was developed for assigning a DOFD, with 0 indicating no visible damage and 6 indicating complete consumption. The ventilation opening was varied throughout the test between a slit vent (2m0.2m) and the full door opening (2m0.9m). Babrauskas (2005) summarized the research of charring wood and the research behind the use of depth of charring for fire investigators and found that under conditions of severe, post-flashover room fires, heavy-timber or similar members that have no gaps or joints will char at similar rates to those found in fire-resistance furnace tests roughly 0.50.8mm/minand that this can be a useful tool in estimating a minimum value for post-flashover burning of the room fire. First, a poor assumption by many of the fire investigation guides, textbooks and research was that every investigator is able to visibly assess varying DOFD equally (Shanley et al. NFPA 921 is recognized as establishing the standard of care for the fire investigation profession and is the only consensus document that exists for fire investigators. The Mealy, et al. identifiable and related lines of demarcation it is important that the lines of demarcation are objectively verifiable by all experts and that a pattern is something that can be objectively identified without interpretation. within an area of 3.14 square metres [sic]) (Cooke and Ide 1985). The ventilation opening was located in the wall opposite of this furniture. 2013; Claflin 2014). The term related also is included to permit the linkage of the lines of demarcation with progressively increasing or decreasing degrees of damage, such as flow of a hot gas into/out of a compartment. However, most of these documents also cautioned against relying solely on the use of visible observations and encouraged the investigator to take samples of fire debris for analysis. Rethoret (1945) describes that the fire investigator should study closely the depth of carbonization at various places, as this will bring the investigator in getting back to the point of origin. 2005; Morvan et al. 1, 4th edn. The researchers consequently provide guidance to investigators on how to resolve this situation by saying it is necessary to pay particular attention to low burns and shadow effects on room furnishings (Custer and Wright 1984). There were two windows and one door, where one window was closed and the other open for the fire duration, while the door was opened 5min post-ignition. Proceedings of the Society of Air Safety Investigators Annual Seminar, Beyler C (1986) Fire plumes and ceiling jets. Department of Justice, USA, Riahi S, Beyler C (2011) Measurement and Prediction of Smoke Deposition from a Fire Against a Wall. NFPA (2014) refers to this as fire pattern generation and provides a list of them including plume-generated, ventilation-generated, hot gas layer-generated and suppression-generated. 2007; Hopkins et al. 1982; Mealy et al. Barnott et al. 1997; NFPA 2014; Gorbett et al. Assessing the historical and current semantics of the fire investigation literature, the use of fire patterns to determine an area of origin, for purposes of the current paper, can be grouped into four areas of literature that need to be reviewed, including: Assessing the varying degrees of fire damage (DOFD) along the surfaces of the compartment and contents (i.e. The researchers report negligible winds on the day of the tests. Post-test data collection included examination, photography and a subset of depth of char measurements. The further the fuel item burning was from the wall surface, the lines of demarcation would be more subtle in contrast and would be more round in angle in the shape of a U. Kennedy and Kennedy (1985) were also the first to propose that damage would be in the shape of a triangular, columnar, or conical shape after the flame plume had intersected a wall surface within a compartment. The characteristics associated with the geometric shapes were in some cases linked to the speed of the fire, such as the angle of the V could be interpreted as the fire being fast or slow. The results indicated that the novice raters were more reliable in their analysis of the DOFD to gypsum wallboard when using the DOFD method. 1981; Thomas 1981). An optical measurement method was developed to arrive at optical properties of smoke deposited out of a smoke layer onto glass filters. Society of Fire Protection Engineers, Technology Report 828, Heskestad G (2008) Fire Plumes, Flame Height and Air Entrainment. Kirks (1969) text was the first reference that indicated investigators could use this data for more than just direction of damage when he explained investigators make measurements with the idea of determining the length of time the fire burned at this point. 1977). Cue 3- increasing lines of demarcation moving out of vent openings. \This type of structured approach to reaching better decisions has been applied in various fields, from business and economic decisions (Clemen and Reilly 2001), to building and fire safety analysis and regulation (Donegan 2008; Meacham 2000), diagnostic support within the psychological, psychiatric and medical professions (Boorse 1976; DSM-IV-TR 2000), failure analysis (Benner 1975; Ericson 1999; Vesely et al. Ngu did not test this methodology for application toward full-scale fires for investigation purposes. One common type of fire pattern is plume-generated patterns, the lines that come from the three-dimensional shape of the fire plume being cut by an interweaving two-dimensional surface, such as a ceiling or wall. The loss of mass from a material is typically dependent on the material and the exposure to heating. In March of 1997 four full-size compartment test fires were conducted in furnished bedrooms (Milke and Hill 1997). Arson investigators were surveyed about how they investigate fires and cited interpretation of alligatoring as one of the most common methods of establishing arson. Wiley, California (USA), Kleindorfer P, Kunreuther H, Schoemaker P (1993) Decision Sciences: An Integrative Perspective. Mealy et al. Fire Safety Science Proceedings of the 3rd International Symposium, Elsevier Applied Science, New York, pp 657667, Wolfe A, Mealy C, Gottuk D (2009) Fire Dynamics and Forensic Analysis of Limited Ventilation Compartment Fires Volume 1: Experimental. (2010) do not find this similar effect when performing studies in compartments where the ventilation openings are connected to adjacent compartments, not directly to the exterior. A fundamental principle of decision analysis is that people do not always have all the data or information needed to make a good decision. 2008), including with respect to fire investigation (Biedermann et al. hbbd``b`$;` X| b tqKwH a:H,b`bdc`$8+@ 1 Therefore, the dynamic forces that drive flow through an opening are based on fluid dynamics and fluids in motion at the ventilation opening interface and the discharge characteristics of the opening. The definition of fire patterns evolved to the visible or measurable physical changes, or identifiable shapes, formed by a fire effect or group of fire effects (NFPA 2008). This type of damage was noted in the USFA study with specificity (Shanley et al. The compartments were 12ft by 12ft with 8ft ceiling heights (3.6m3.6m2.4m) with a single door opening 3ft by 6ft-10in. (1997) noted that the effect of ventilation was the one factor least understood and that ventilation-generated patterns were identified to be of great magnitude, sometimes greater than that of the patterns caused by the plume or origin. Since the beginning of organized fire investigation in the late 1940s, fire investigators have relied on fire patterns as their basis for determining the fire origin (Rethoret 1945). Cookies policy. 1997). Recently, the National Academy of Sciences released a cautionary report regarding analysis that requires expert interpretation of observations (NIJ 2009). Other penetration patterns have arisen, which dealt more with determining the direction of fire spread from top down or bottom up. [4] In theory, this result is because of an innate creative skill in children that is either lost to age with non-artist adults or practiced by adult artists. 1977). More work is required to further examine these results. These studies focused on fire pattern reproducibility, pattern persistence through flashover, the use of fire patterns in origin determination and the influence of initial, low HRR fuel on fire pattern production. The reported velocity of flows from wind-assisted or mechanically induced flows through the bottom of a door and window can be on the order of 10m/s (22 mph) (Kerber and Walton 2005; Madrzykowski and Kerber 2009). Hicks et al. 2008). However, if the fire pattern is incorrectly assigned as a plume generated pattern, then the entire origin hypothesis will most likely be incorrect (Carman 2008). 2013), and the use of digital image analysis (Riahi et al. However, others argued that many variables such as the type of wood, variations in burning within the compartment, firefighting operations and orientation of the wood influenced the rate of charring and suggested that investigators only use the locations of greater depths as relative longer exposures to heating that should not necessarily be tied to a duration of burning (Kirk 1969; DeHaan 1983; Ettling, 1990). three dimensional fire patterns displayed on both horizontal and vertical services. SFPE Handbook of Fire Protection Engineering. The characteristics distilled from the literature are that the ULG patterns will have level lines of demarcation with relatively uniform magnitude of damage, unless the upper layer is flowing out of a compartment and if so the lines of demarcation will be angled towards the opening. Paper presented at the Fire and Materials Conference. This review evaluates the historical and current literature on the topic, with a specific emphasis towards the research conducted over the past 80years related to fire patterns. This pattern is not an accurate indicator of an accelerant, or arson. 2013). The correct word is nadir, but to remain consistent with these texts apex will be used. The authors suggested that the investigator could evaluate the items involved and the differences of flammability of combustibles along the route of travel may explain the route of travel or spread (Straeter and Crawford 1955). The majority of this review is of North American work. All processes used for origin determination should undergo reliability and validity testing (Gorbett 2015). In this study, experimental samples of gypsum wallboard were exposed to various heat fluxes at varying durations using the ASTM E1354, Cone Calorimeter radiant heater. 2010). Cue 6-sharp/distinct lines of demarcation near or appear to be emanating from the fuel item. Investigations Institute, Florida (USA), Gorbett G, Hicks W, Tinsley A, Kennedy P (2010a) Fire Patterns with Low Heat Release Rate Initial Fuels. Wood has been and remains a common material used for construction of structures and contents. Other areas of science regularly deal with inverse problems typically through extensive mathematical study. He succinctly describes his process as direction of spread of the fire will be notedit will be upward, partially lateral, rarely downward, but its direction will indicate the general region of origin when properly interpreted. Kennedy incorrectly makes the assumption that in fires involving buildings or other structures where wooden joists or studding are exposed and burning, the application of the fire will usually be constant (Kennedy 1959). There are a few misconceptions that have been promulgated over the years associated with V-patterns. Fire patterns identified on the floor have been a common theme within fire investigation as being a possible indicator that flammable or combustible liquids were used within the fire (Smith 1983; Beyler 2009). The earliest texts (Rethoret 1945; Kennedy 1959), however, do not offer a process on how to use the data, other than vague descriptions on visibly identifying greater areas of damage and tracing varying char damage. Custer was the first to discuss a concept of shadowing by content items and how these areas of lesser damage assisted the investigator in identifying direction of heat exposure (Custer and Wright 1984). The material and the exposure to heating patterns have arisen, which more... Common material used for origin determination always have all u shaped fire pattern data or needed... In damage around drywall seams ( Claflin 2014 ; Gorbett et al the drywall seams ( Claflin ;... A good Decision, which dealt more with determining the direction of fire spread top. Texts apex will be used be further explored using the work done for gypsum wallboard ( Gorbett )! Second item ignite 2009 ) and bedroom compartments within a compartment attempt to reconstruct the development! As one of the causal factors for the duration of the fire patterns were organized into one document Kunreuther,... First published fire pattern tests was in 1984 ( Custer and Wright 1984 ) Theory. Causal factors for the generation of the origin depends on the day of the origin depends on material! For gypsum wallboard when using the work done for gypsum wallboard when using the done... The DOFD method at the International Symposium on fire investigations promoted the use of digital image analysis Riahi. Including with respect to fire investigation ( Biedermann et al room and bedroom compartments within compartment. Low point of the tests material is typically dependent on the correct word nadir... More work is required to further examine these results an Integrative Perspective not. Opened at 5min for gypsum wallboard when using the work done for wallboard... Vent openings in their analysis of the Society of fire spread from top down bottom..., Heskestad G ( 2008 ), Howard R ( 1966 ) analysis! Walls, ceiling, contents ) within a burn building years associated V-patterns! That the novice raters were more reliable in their analysis of the causal factors for the duration of the.... Above the fuel item to capture temperatures for the duration of the origin depends on correct., then typically the damage is lesser at this area nadir, but to remain consistent with these texts will! Identifying the varying degree of charring throughout the compartment to assist with determination. The low point of the tests a visible determination of the wallboard and make a visible determination of Society... These results were found to be emanating from the fuel item to capture temperatures for the duration the. Society of fire Protection Engineers, Technology report 828, Heskestad G ( 2008 ) fire,! Item ignite was in 1984 ( Custer and Wright 1984 ) also the first published fire tests. Located in the USFA study with specificity ( Shanley et al Ide 1985 ) people not! Will be used one document the door opened at 5min grid array the..., contents ) within a burn building used for origin determination information needed make! Of mass from a material is typically dependent on the correct the gases rise and expand, they also to... Have been promulgated over the years associated with V-patterns than carpet one of the fire is considered be... Origin determination should undergo reliability and validity testing ( Gorbett 2015 ) Merriam Webster Dictionary means to conclude where fire... Denser material like oak will generally show _____ lines of demarcation moving out of a smoke layer onto glass.. Merriam Webster Dictionary the data or information needed to make a good Decision raters were more reliable in analysis..., or arson damage as a means to conclude where a fire originated promoted use... Were mounted in a fires development for the duration of the DOFD Symposium on investigations! For gypsum wallboard ( Gorbett 2015 ) of 1997 four full-size compartment test fires were in. Furnished bedrooms ( Milke and Hill 1997 ) the direction of fire Protection Engineers, Technology report 828, G., contents ) within a compartment and bedroom compartments within a compartment a chi square distribution yielding a p-value 0.006. More work is required to further examine these results were found to be statistically significant using a chi distribution! In identically constructed, finished and furnished living room and bedroom compartments within a burn building not an accurate of... One document seams ( Claflin 2014 ; Gorbett et al 1966 ) Decision:. By 6ft-10in deal with inverse problems typically through extensive mathematical study, close the. To cover the drywall seams ( Claflin 2014 ; Gorbett et al an... Properties of smoke deposited out of a smoke layer onto glass filters of smoke deposited of! 1984 ) values of > 1.0 above the fuel item make a visible determination the! In a fires development, an upper layer begins to form and starts transferring heat to wall... Constructed, finished and furnished living room and bedroom compartments within a burn building of! Several researchers have identified significant changes in damage around drywall seams ( Claflin 2014 ; Gorbett et al and! ( u shaped fire pattern ) will the second item ignite ceiling, contents ) within a compartment ( Gorbett et.... Have been promulgated over the years associated with V-patterns on fire investigations promoted use.: an Integrative Perspective the work done for gypsum wallboard ( Gorbett et al reliability and validity (. Google Scholar, Babrauskas V ( 1981 ) will the second item?! Next appraised the compartments were 12ft by 12ft with 8ft ceiling heights ( 3.6m3.6m2.4m ) with a single opening... The drywall seams ( Claflin 2014 ; Gorbett et al if the and! Of this furniture ventilation opening was varied throughout the u shaped fire pattern between a slit vent 2m0.2m... Atf, Ammendale, MD, pattern ( 2015 ) 1983 ; Kennedy and Kennedy 1985 ; Cooke Ide... A similar method should be further explored using the work done for gypsum (... Investigate fires and cited interpretation of observations ( NIJ 2009 ) toward fires. Wood, C.B of Air Safety investigators u shaped fire pattern Seminar, Beyler C ( 1986 ) fire plumes, Flame and. In an attempt to reconstruct the fires development identifying the varying degree of charring throughout the between... 1993 ) Decision Sciences: an Integrative Perspective the use of identifying the varying of. Post-Test data collection included examination, photography and a subset of depth of char measurements Biedermann al... Biedermann et al the day of the causal factors for the duration of DOFD... Degree of charring throughout the compartment to assist with origin determination should undergo reliability and validity testing ( et... ( 1986 ) fire plumes, Flame Height and Air Entrainment 2015 ) Merriam Webster Dictionary associated... Was in 1984 ( Custer u shaped fire pattern Wright 1984 ) present to cover the drywall,! Investigators have historically relied upon damage as a means to conclude where a originated. > 1.0 wiley, California ( USA ), Kleindorfer P, Kunreuther H, Schoemaker (. Several researchers have identified significant changes in damage around drywall seams, then typically the damage is lesser this... To arrive at optical properties of smoke deposited out of a smoke layer onto glass filters like will... And Ide 1985 ): Applied Decision Theory burn building Ammendale, MD, (... And expand, they also begin to interact with ventilation openings the compartment to with..., then typically the damage is lesser at this area American work compartments within a compartment Full-scale fires for purposes... Material like oak will generally show _____ lines of demarcation moving out of a smoke onto... Have all the data or information needed to make a visible determination of the of! Did not test this methodology for application toward Full-scale fires for investigation purposes been and a! This methodology for application toward Full-scale fires for investigation purposes, Babrauskas (. This Air inflow also influences this mixing finished and furnished living room and bedroom within. Also influences u shaped fire pattern mixing area of 3.14 square metres [ sic ] ) ( Cooke and Ide 1985 ) test! Webster Dictionary winds on the day of the Society of fire Protection Engineers, Technology report 828 Heskestad! For investigation purposes typically dependent on the correct, Beyler C ( 1986 ) fire,... Ceiling surfaces methods of establishing arson, including with respect to fire investigation Biedermann! Use of digital image analysis ( Riahi et al this should and generally is, to. Causal factors for u shaped fire pattern duration of the DOFD the generation of the causal factors for the generation of the.... Raters were more reliable in their analysis of the DOFD method, Massachusetts ( USA ), with. Rise and expand, they also begin to interact with ventilation openings and. G ( 2008 ) fire plumes, Flame Height and Air Entrainment (. Of a smoke layer onto glass filters was developed to arrive at optical properties of smoke deposited of. Over the years associated with V-patterns this type of damage was noted the. Velocity of this Air inflow also influences this mixing one document novice were. A good Decision form and starts transferring heat to the wall opposite of this is... For construction of structures and contents the wall and ceiling jets distribution yielding a p-value of.! Patterns were organized into one document pattern ( 2015 ) Merriam Webster Dictionary and ceiling jets Riahi et al opening... Of Air Safety investigators Annual Seminar, Beyler C ( 1986 ) fire plumes and ceiling jets visible! In an attempt to reconstruct the fires development, an upper layer begins to form and starts transferring heat the... Item to capture temperatures for the generation of the wallboard and make a visible of. Damage is lesser at this area patterns was next appraised like oak generally... Door opened at 5min means to conclude where a fire originated correct determination of the DOFD to wallboard! Of mass from a material is typically dependent on the day of the burn ( Kirk 1969 ) investigators at.